Gutter and downpipe quote checklist
12 checks for comparing gutter and downpipe quotes on a Pakenham 3810 home before you sign.
Gutter quotes are hard to compare when each provider measures, describes and prices the job differently. This checklist sets out 12 areas where quotes for gutter replacement, downpipes, box gutters and related work on Pakenham 3810 homes most often differ. Use it before accepting any quote. It is general guidance, not legal advice.
How to use the checklist
Put the quotes side by side. For each section below, mark whether each quote covers the point, excludes it or says nothing. Anything left unsaid is a question for the provider. A lower total often means a smaller scope, a cheaper material or an assumption about access, not better value.
Give every provider the same information at the start: the problems you have seen, photos, the house’s storeys and roof type, nearby trees and whether a tank is connected. Quotes based on the same brief are much easier to compare.
1. Who is quoting and their licence
- Business name, ABN and contact details on the quote
- Name of the person who inspected and who will do the work
- Plumbing licence or registration number for roofing or drainage work
- Public liability insurance, with a certificate if you want one
Work on gutters, downpipes and stormwater counts as plumbing under Victorian rules. Larger or more valuable jobs generally have to be done by a licensed or registered plumber who lodges a compliance certificate afterwards. Look up the quoting plumber on the Building and Plumbing Commission register (the commission replaced the Victorian Building Authority on 1 July 2026) and note the licence number beside the quote.
2. Is the scope the same in every quote?
Check that each quote describes:
- Which parts of the house are included: front, sides, rear, garage, verandah, sheds
- The metres of gutter to be replaced or repaired
- The number of downpipes, and whether they are replaced
- Box gutters, valleys, rain heads and spreaders, if any
- Removal and disposal of old gutters and downpipes
Vague wording such as “replace gutters to house” leaves room for disagreement about garages, carports and verandahs.
3. Profile, size and material
| Item | What to look for |
|---|---|
| Profile | Quad, square line, half round, high-front or other |
| Size | Whether the gutter size is the same as now or larger |
| Material | Pre-painted steel, unpainted coated steel, aluminium or other |
| Colour | Named colour, matched to roof or trim |
| Downpipes | Round or rectangular, size and material |
| Brackets | Internal, external or over-strap, and spacing |
Our gutter profiles and materials comparison explains the choices.
4. Are outlets, fall and overflow addressed?
A replacement is the time to fix drainage design problems. Look for:
- Number and position of outlets and downpipes for each roof section
- Fall toward each outlet
- Overflow measures so water spills outside, not into the eaves
- Treatment of spreaders from upper roofs
- Overflow provisions for box gutters
Roof drainage is designed under AS/NZS 3500.3. A licensed plumber should be able to explain how they sized gutters and downpipes for your roof. If one quote adds downpipes and another does not, ask both why.
5. Fascia, roof edge and hidden damage
Many problems only show once old gutters come off. Check how each quote handles:
- Rotten timber fascia: repair, replacement, or a steel system
- Rotten rafter ends
- Tiles that need lifting and rebedding at the gutter line
- Metal roof sheet ends that need turning down
- Sarking that does not drain into the gutter
Ask for a rate or allowance for hidden fascia rot so you are not surprised. The fascia and barge repairs page explains these repairs.
6. Stormwater connections
Moving or adding downpipes may need new underground pipes to connect to the stormwater system. Check:
- Whether new or relocated downpipes are connected to stormwater
- Whether existing stormwater pipes will be tested or camera inspected
- Who handles blocked or broken underground pipes found during the job
- Where water will discharge
The guide to downpipes and stormwater explains how the system should connect to the legal point of discharge.
7. Tanks, diverters and guards
If gutters feed a rainwater tank, or you want guards:
- Leaf diverters and first flush devices included or not
- Reconnection of tank pipework
- Gutter guard product, material and fixing method
- Whether guards are fitted after cleaning and repairs
The gutter guards page compares guard types, and the rainwater tank connections page covers tank plumbing.
8. Access and safety
- Ladders, scaffolding, edge protection or an elevated work platform
- Whether equipment hire is included
- Roof anchors to be installed or used
- Protection of garden beds, paving, pools and decks under the eaves
- Arrangements near overhead power lines
Two-storey homes and sloping blocks vary most between quotes because of access. Ask each provider how they will reach the roof.
9. Asbestos
Ask each provider whether they saw any grey fibre cement sheeting in the eaves, gutters or downpipes. On houses from before the 2003 national asbestos ban it is common, and some of it can only be removed by a licensed asbestos removalist. The quote should say how suspected material will be handled. WorkSafe Victoria has a homeowner page on this.
10. Price, payments and variations
| Item | Questions |
|---|---|
| Total | Fixed price or estimate? GST included? |
| Deposit | How much and when? |
| Progress payments | Linked to what? |
| Allowances | Which items, such as fascia repair, are allowances that may change? |
| Variations | How will extra work be priced and approved? |
The Building and Plumbing Commission and Consumer Affairs Victoria publish guidance on deposits, contracts and payments for domestic building work. Avoid paying the full amount before work starts.
11. Compliance certificate and records
Ask whether a compliance certificate will be issued and when. Ask for:
- The certificate, if applicable
- Product names and colours
- Photos of the finished work, especially box gutters and areas you cannot see
- Warranty details
Keep these with your house records.
12. Timing, weather and warranty
- Expected start date and duration
- How the house will be protected if rain arrives mid-job
- Workmanship warranty, and its length and conditions
- Product warranty conditions, such as maintenance requirements
Red flags
- A price far below others without a clear reason
- Pressure to decide on the spot
- Requests for full payment upfront or cash only
- No licence or registration details for plumbing work
- No written quote, or a quote without business details
- Unwillingness to explain fall, outlets or overflow
None of these prove a problem, but each deserves a follow-up question.
A comparison table to fill in
| Point | Quote A | Quote B | Quote C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Licence or registration checked | |||
| Scope matches my brief | |||
| Profile, size, material, colour | |||
| Downpipes and outlets | |||
| Overflow measures | |||
| Fascia and hidden damage | |||
| Stormwater connections | |||
| Access equipment | |||
| Compliance certificate | |||
| Payment schedule | |||
| Warranty |
Get comparable quotes in the first place
Write a short brief before anyone visits, and give the same brief to each provider. Include the roof type, storeys, problems you have noticed, photos and any tank or guard plans. Walk each provider around the house and ask them to show you what they see from the ladder or roof, with photos. If one provider recommends something the others did not mention, such as extra downpipes or a box gutter overflow, ask the others what they think. That way you are comparing the same job rather than different jobs.
Questions for specific jobs
Different jobs need different extra checks. The service pages list them:
- Gutter replacement: sizing, profile, overflow
- Box gutter repairs: overflow provisions, materials, roof sheet removal
- Downpipe repairs: cause of blockage, connection to stormwater
- Gutter realignment: fascia condition, bracket spacing
After you accept
Confirm acceptance in writing, naming the quote and its date and any agreed changes. Take photos before work starts. Once the job is finished, check the work from the ground, run a hose in each gutter if it is safe to reach, and watch the system in the next heavy rain. Raise any problems with the provider promptly.
Questions about cleaning and debris during the job
Replacement work creates debris: old gutters, brackets, sealant, rivets, metal offcuts and swarf. Check how each quote handles it. Metal swarf left on a roof rusts and can stain roofing and gutters, so ask whether the provider will sweep the roof and gutters at the end. Old gutters should be removed from the property unless you want to keep them for scrap. Ask whether garden beds and paving under the work will be protected, and whether the provider will clean up at the end of each day if the job runs over several days.
Checking the work when it is finished
Before making the final payment, check:
- Gutters run in straight, even lines without visible dips
- Brackets are evenly spaced and secure
- Joints, corners and stop ends are neat and sealed
- Downpipes are fixed with brackets and connected at ground level
- Old materials and debris have been removed
- Any damaged tiles or fascia have been repaired as agreed
A water test with a hose, done by the provider or with them present, confirms water reaches the outlets. Ask for the compliance certificate if one applies.
Licence checks in practice
Checking a plumber’s licence or registration takes a few minutes. Search the Building and Plumbing Commission’s public register using the name or licence number on the quote, and confirm that the licence covers the type of work, such as roofing (stormwater) or drainage. Check that the name matches the business or person who will do the work. If the business uses subcontractors, ask who will hold the licence for your job and sign the compliance certificate. Keep a note of the licence number with your quote.
Getting help reading a quote
If a quote uses terms you do not understand, such as sumps, spitters, stop ends or over-straps, ask the provider to explain them. A provider who explains the scope clearly is easier to work with when questions come up during the job.
Request quotes through this site
To get quotes to compare, describe your job on the gutter quote request form. We may pass the details to up to three independent local businesses, who can contact you to inspect and quote. We do not prepare or check quotes ourselves. Yes Right Pty Ltd operates this referral site.